Bad pizza

Iā€™ve ate so much pizza out of the garbage

5 Likes

This thread brought to you by:

Their model isnā€™t as much ā€œall you can eatā€ as it is ā€œall you care to eat.ā€

5 Likes

England, roadside rest stop, early 90ā€™s at a location called Happy Eater (whose logo is rather ironic)


I had eaten my fair share of American school lunch pizza up to this point, but this was like: crumbly bread, dry cheese, not even sweet ketchup. Horrible, just horrible. Even slapping together scraps in my kitchen I have made better.

3 Likes

A thorough take on Ciciā€™s Pizza

Iā€™ve had loads of bad pizza, from pizza bagel bites to frozen to delivery from ā€œproperā€ restaurants. The worst in recent memory I believe I mentioned on the podcast. It was one of those pizza places where there are 8 ā€œbusinessesā€ operating out of one spot that actually makes all of it, and they keep changing the name and fudging their location so you will think a new place opened up once their reviews get too bad. Anyway, the one time we got fooled by that the pizza was cold, not fully cooked (some raw dough even), inexplicably sweet, oily, with cheese that tasted of nothing. Itā€™s the only pizza Iā€™ve ever thrown away.

(oh yes I also got mildly ill even though I only ate one slice)

5 Likes

The two most memorably bad pizzas that Iā€™ve had; one was from a takeaway place in my city called Chicago Bulls that I had in 2014. This abomination had a huge crust, was super dry and cardboard, and had very little cheese but by far worst of all the meat was undercooked!

The other worst one I had was in Paris in 2007. The base was still doughlike, the sauce was separating from itself and was watery, and it wasnā€™t a particularly pleasant experience at all. I ended up spending the rest of the day in my room being sick! Thanks.

3 Likes

A post was merged into an existing topic: Ep. 362 - Official Mario Bong, with Mathew Kumar

One time my grandpap tried to cook a Red Baron pizza on a gas grill. It was burnt in some spots, underdone in other; it was a wild mess.

I heard this in a YouTube video recently and it felt accurate to me: the pizza novice judges the pizza top-down. They care most about the toppings, then the cheese, then the sauce and crust. The pizza aficionado, by contrast, judges it bottom-up. The crust is by far the most important part, then the sauce, then the cheese and toppings need to just not get in the way. I thought that was interesting and mostly true. All about that nice crust.

6 Likes

At a work function once they asked all of us what we wanted to order, and 70% of attendees said they wanted vegan pizza. Unfortunately the pizza place didnā€™t understand how to make an appealing vegan pizza, and so sent over five crusts with a small amount of sauce and a layer of broccoli and red onionsā€”roasted but not otherwise dressed, seasoned, whateverā€”on top.
At the end of the event almost all the vegan pizza was uneaten, so I, having myself not eaten any of it and at that time always on the hunt for free food, took it home (five boxes). The crust wasnā€™t bad but everything else was. I threw most of it away.

3 Likes

what i discovered through eating dreadful kebab shop pizza fairly often in my student years is that sometimes the places with the foulest mystery meat toppings could usually put out a serviceable margarita. thereā€™s no hiding it, they are frozen deep dish bases but iā€™d take one of those over the ā€œwood fired neapolitanā€ style places that give you red water on thin raw dough with scant anything else on top. sometimes those places have the brass knackers to put a basil leaf on there. that plant deserves better.

3 Likes

After a conference I had been to, I had some time before going to the airport and I was hungry. So I explored and found a ā€œpizzaā€ place. The warning signs?

  1. They also sold chicken (but not with any sense of specialization or care; this wasnā€™t a pizza and wings place or a place proud of its drummies or anything)
  2. They only sold personal sized pizzas
  3. That day was their last day of operation
  4. After I ordered, their method of cooking was basically putting it in a tiny oven

What came out was at least an order of magnitude worse than the Pizza Hut personal pizzas they sell sometimes at university dining halls. The cheese tasted funky and was rubbery. The bread was most minimally cooked. Iā€™d done goofed up.

4 Likes

The adult in me knows that Hot Dog Pizza can only be bad pizza but I am really just a six year old in a 33 year old body so almost always whenever I order pizza it is Hot Dog Pizza. However, when an Italian is present I will restrain myself and order something that doesnā€™t disrespect their amazing food culture.

5 Likes

Except times where the place I ordered from screwed up (once got a sauceless pizza), Iā€™m not actually sure Iā€™ve ever had bad pizza. Iā€™ve had pizza that is less good than other pizza, but never to the point where I would say itā€™s bad or that I refused the pizza. Maybe I am just easy to please.

3 Likes

The worst pizzas Iā€™ve probably had were all from frozen growing up and I attribute that to my mom overcooking everything but Iā€™ve still instinctually avoided buying frozen pizzas with my groceries as an adult. Maybe I should buy some and repair my relationship (with the pizza I mean).

I once got a personal pie from this place up the street from my last apartment. This town doesnā€™t have the foot traffic to support slices even when advertisedā€”they are either not available or extremely staleā€”so paying extra for a whole personal-sized pizza was not my first choice. It was some kind of margherita but the topped area was like shrunken and the crust went way beyond what should be allowable surface area for crust. And the sauce was dry. It fucking sucked and I was angry because it wasnā€™t cheap.

The best pizza I had in Toronto was a puttanesca that the place I got it from took off their menu. Hard to talk about bad pizza without also talking about good pizza, sorry lol. Iā€™ve had a lot of pizzas in TO besides where the toppings were singed as shit or they were mediocre in some other way.

5 Likes

Also: Hawaiian pizza is good, actually, but easy for me to get sick of. Iā€™ve known a few people who will order it regularly and Iā€™m likeā€¦ again? Meat lovers is the same thing, but maybe worse because of all the salt it adds. Big fan of vegetables on pizza right here.

7 Likes

I put it with the description as here itā€™s known as a Napolitaine, which I know describes a style of pizza more than the toppings themselves. But it was the same style of pizza so as you can imagine it was amazing.

Iā€™d share a slice or two with you of course, because us anchovy eaters have to stick together. Mostly as those that donā€™t avoid us!!

4 Likes

I canā€™t believe youā€™ve never told me this. And also, most fucked up American guy Iā€™ve ever heard. What do you mean ā€œitā€™s easier than decidingā€? What kind of screwed up gremlin logic is that? Does this man-shaped goblin eat pizza with only tomato sauce on the regular? This should be criminal.

5 Likes

Iā€™m surprised I apparently havenā€™t told you that story, because I feel like Iā€™ve told it alot.

1 Like

I am fuming just thinking about this guy now. The real question is if youā€™ve actually had Chicago style pizza if there is nothing on it.

4 Likes

Thatā€™s a sociopathā€™s opinion, change my mind.

6 Likes