On the most recent episode of the podcast, @“exodus”#3 mentioned that if you take one or two good episodes of the Simpsons from each season that followed season 10, you'd have one last good season.
I'm a diehard fan of seasons two through eight, and I also wish they'd let this series die already, so this idea appeals to me!
(I want to go on record as saying that season nine is the last good season, and that season eight is the last great season, but 10 is a nice cutoff, so let's go with that.)
Let's see if we can get to 22 nominated episodes – the most common number of episodes per season. Nominations must come from season 11 or later.
To get us started, I'll nominate The Dad Who Knew Too Little (season 14, episode 8). This is the one where Homer hires a private investigator to spy on Lisa.
Here's a clip. In two minutes, it contains: a shocking number of good jokes (which are more rewarding for longtime fans), Homer being an idiot (multiple times), non sequitur cutaways to beloved minor characters, and genuine sentimentality. In short, everything that makes the Simpsons great.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=44yB5Skg4t4
And as a bonus, anyone who gives a heck about this thread will also probably be interested in reading this incredible book-length essay about how the Simpsons became the Zombie Simpsons: https://deadhomersociety.wordpress.com/zombiesimpsons/
_THE LAST GOOD SIMPSONS SEASON_
Ep. 1 - E-I-E-I-(Annoyed Grunt) (S11 E05) @"Gaagaagiins"#429
Ep. 2 - Skinner's Sense of Snow (S12 E08) @"2501"#281
Ep. 3 - Trilogy of Error (S12 E18) @"robinhoodie"#120
Ep. 4 - Weekend at Burnsie's (S13 E16) @zm1704
Ep. 5 - The Dad Who Knew Too Little (S14 E08) @"whatsarobot"#243
Ep. 6 - Bart-Mangled Banner (S15 E21) @"scoregem"#239
Ep. 7 - The Road to Cincinnati (S32 E08) @"Video_Game_King"#136